Show me a humanoid robot that can do that.
Show me a humanoid robot that can do that.
It's definitely not several tries. I've actually witnessed that very recently with my daughter. It takes a child literally several thousand attempts and falls (around a hundred falls per day) and 1,000 hours of dedicated practice, before they can make their first step without holding anything [1]. And a lot more until they can walk reliably.
[1] Source: Becoming You, S1E2, from 21:30
Don't get me wrong, I'm not claiming that Machine Learning is as generally capable as animals/humans, and I don't entirely disagree with the OP (i.e. I don't know if our current approach has a chance of scaling to human-level capabilities). I just don't think computation-wise it compares that badly to animals, considering that it's the result of a few decades of work, largely on repurposed silicon
The puppies are benefitting from a different type of "learning" process of course, in having genetic instincts tuned by many generations of ancestors who had good enough genetic wiring of motor capabilities and instincts sufficiently well attuned to their environments to survive. Humans have weaker priors and reach physical and mental maturity much more slowly but ultimately achieve greater mastery of their environment by learning it from first principles or communication with other humans (there may be a tradeoff, and of course humans are so good at protecting their young over years of infancy the early instincts aren't that important to retain)
Human babies are born at a stage that would be considered premature for most mammals. Because of the limitations on the size of the head, they can't afford to develop enough in utero, like deer or even dolphins can.
This is an interesting paradox in machine learning: the data that people use to (ostensibly!) simulate the human mind is simultaneously way too much, and not nearly enough. It's way too much in that humans can, e.g., learn to generate and recognise natural language without having to train on the entire World Wide Web of a corpus. And it's not nearly enough because humans can do that only after billions of years of evolution, which amount to training on all the data in the real world, not a mere few petabytes of data on the internet [1].
This paradox has to be resolved (i.e. understood) before we can really compare humans minds to artificial systems. Unfortunately, I don't see anybody trying. In machine learning so far people are happy to just plug in the data and turn the crank- something will come out eventually.
______________
[1] Source: https://archive.li/EY9ak
As mentioned in a sibling comment, HN anthropomorphizes AI too much. And is too optimistic about it. I just don't see the results and the value, people trip up all over themselves to congratulate themselves and the researches, yet 99.99% of the problems in the world persist.
I am one of these a-holes that wants to see results when money are invested. It still comes as a shock to some apparently.
AI takes a shortcut around having a timeline of a trillion different versions history optimizing the learning algorithm and putting the successful ones in a timeline, but at a cost of trillions of operations to teach it.
TL;DR, the problem space is huge and evidently must be iterated.
It doesn't. We are steering it. And I doubt that we know better than the natural evolution.
Its a joy to watch a child grow up, but also its super interesting watching them figure out the most basic shit. Would highly recommend if you get the opportunity.
Bringing Up Turing’s ‘Child-Machine’ by Susan G. Sterrett
https://link.springer.com/chapter/10.1007/978-3-642-30870-3_...
That's not OK.
"Walking" at least on dry land has been around 420 million years or so. The locomotion part of the learning algorithms has been around a very, very long time, and it's going to be very hard to duplicate the efficiency that nature brute forced.
Nature has not hype optimized human level intelligence. Really human intelligence is at the limits of birth. Our heads can't be any larger at birth or we'll kill the mother too much of the time. Then the human body has a power budget that's been the defining factor of human/animal survival for just about forever. Humans were already 'smart' before we invented agriculture and excess fuel storage.
AI takes that a step further. We're not using reversible computing so the heat generated is pretty high. We've not been doing it very long and our algorithms are not optimal in any sense. But what we do have that nature does not is nearly unlimited energy, nearly unlimited cooling capacity, and a lot of computer systems working on the problem at once. In an evolutionary sense we're doing closer to the bacteria method, we have a lot of different experiments going on at once and at least a few of them are likely to be fruitful.
Personally I hope the AI development is no insanely rapid. Rapid and powerful changes in society can cause as many problems as they find fixes for, and the pace of society change is not that fast.
Not sure if the AI area, represented by human supervisors, does so in such an objective and ruthless manner as nature does.
If there's no fitness function and natural selection then the AI area might be doomed to meander and go in circles for centuries.
These and exactly these are the tech advancements that I imagined as a teenager would improve people's lives!
I just feel that 99% of the technology nowadays does not improve almost anyone's life. It gets easier and easier to be jaded and lose hope.
But your story is very reassuring and nice to read. Thanks for sharing!