that seems obviously falsifiable. California taxes are quite high and the state of California seems to be a great deal more successful than just about any other state in the nation. It seems like the test has been run and the results are available.
"Red states" tend to favor tax structures that are regressive and place greater burden on low/middle income people. "Blue states" often try and tax wealth and corporate income and use the money to provide more services.
Plus, obviously provided services can make up for the lack of taxes. I'm just saying lower taxes, all other things being equal, are a good thing.