I don't think most people necessarily disagree with this:

(1) The people who think that the market can be beat don't think most people can do it. They think most people can't but that they're special and can.

Think most people agree with (2) and (4) as well. They just don't like the implications re: society and God that come with it. To the extent they get rejected it's to preserve the viability of the notions they hold.

They admit (5) is something most people agree with.

(3) and (6) they whittle down their extreme position to what most people agree with

(7) is the closest to delivering what the title claims. But ultimately "better" is subjective and while I largely agree with the point it's not exactly an objective truth.