I find that in Lisp, for example, I'm able to do partial, tentative refactorings, where I sort-of change something as an experiment, just enough that it works in one example case, but don't completely refactor everything to be consistent with the change yet, because I'm not sure if I really want the change or not. That kind of thing is really hard to push through in languages that care more about static types, and I often find myself thinking something along the lines of: yes I know that function there isn't updated with the new type signature, but I'm only planning to try this out initially with one choice of parameters, and I know that in that case the function isn't even called, so please just run the damn program!
otherfunc = undefined
otherfuncReal :: ...
otherfuncReal = ...
The best exploratory programming I've seen in haskell also does this for types to some extent; you know you're writing music, so you start with something like: data Music -- stubbed in data type with no constructor
Then maybe you decide it involves a series of notes with duration, so you change it: data Music = [(Note, Duration)]
data Note -- stub
type Duration = IntIs this also true of Ocaml? I have experience in neither, but my understanding from reading up on this says Ocaml and Haskell are roughly equivalent, and if anything - Ocaml is even more expressive.
Anyone with real world experience who can comment on this?
OCaml is also strict by default, with optional laziness, whereas Haskell is the opposite. This could be seen as either an advantage or a disadvantage, but either way, it is a very fundamental difference.
If you are considering learning one or the other, I'd advocate for Haskell purely on the basis of it being the closest to mainstream of all the static functional languages. There is a huge variety of libraries available on Hackage, and the community is very active, welcoming, and friendly. Haskell (GHC in particular) is also the laboratory in which the majority of interesting FP research is currently being done, if you care about that at all.
Or just learn both languages, so you can compare the benefits and disadvantages for yourself. :)
The main difference is the lack of purity, which means that the side effects of a function aren't part of a function's type. It also doesn't have the wide variety of extensions which you can use to do really crazy stuff (like verifiably correct red-black trees, https://github.com/yairchu/red-black-tree/blob/master/RedBla...).
http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2622166
http://www.cs.washington.edu/education/courses/cse505/98au/s...
They're roughly equivalent the way Python and Ruby are roughly equivalent, or Common Lisp and Scheme. From any other linguistic paradigm, yeah, they're extremely close. But from one to the other, it feels like there is a tremendous gulf.
A lot of the benefits tmhedberg is talking about come from I/O being a monad in Haskell and the lack of "assignables," which constrains your ability to mix side-effects and state changes with pure code. Of course, you can defeat it if you really try (MVars and unsafePerformIO) but it's not the kind of thing you would do accidentally. And you could achieve a lot of the same benefits in OCaml by writing monadic standard libraries and never using refs.
So, if by "expressive" you mean the type system allows you to express complex relationships, Haskell is more expressive. But if by "expressive" you mean the language allows you to express calculations in more ways, OCaml is more expressive. In my experience, "expressiveness" is usually a foil for some other attribute and doesn't usually illuminate the debate much.
In the end, they're just tools, albeit with overlapping purposes. OCaml is easier to learn and compiles faster, Haskell raises your confidence in the code and has cooler tricks. Both are fascinating and stunningly better than lots of other options. If I had to choose which one to learn today, I'd look at some example code in both and ask myself which one I want to be staring at for the next six months.