-some US agencies don’t outright reject it
-labs around the world work on SARS viruses
-early people said it may have leaks (and these people subsequently retracted those statements after research)
-china
And that’s literally it. What exactly is so convincing? People who actually study virus origins still seem to believe that Covid has markers of natural evolution. Lab leak theory tends to side step that fact though.
The lab leak conspiracy theorists put more weight in to a head of department of energy over the virologists who state that he’s probably wrong.
Do you have any papers from scientists that back up the lab leak?
Repeating the same thing does not count as an argument, dammit.
https://www.biorxiv.org/content/10.1101/2022.10.10.511625v1
I can at least repeat their argument correctly, though.
You've also grossly mischaracterized the evidence for a research-related origin. For example, it's not that "labs around the world work on SARS viruses"--the WIV was one of only two labs in the world (with UNC) genetically manipulating coronaviruses in ways consistent with SARS-CoV-2, and has the largest collection of novel sarbecoviruses anywhere.
David Relman (of Stanford) published a note in 2020, which I believe has aged quite well:
https://www.pnas.org/doi/pdf/10.1073/pnas.2021133117
Many other impeccably-credentialed academics consider this origin to be an open question. Bluntly, I don't think you're well-informed here. (Did you know that the 1977 flu killed ~700k people, and is uncontroversially accepted to have arisen from a research accident? If not, does that shift your priors on research-origin pandemics?) I would urge you to learn more from scientific sources, instead of repeating shallow headline claims.
I also haven't followed this very closely, so if there is great specific evidence that I'm unaware of, I apologize. I'm not trying to advocate a particular position here, just trying to explain why the lab leak theory is convincing to people. In fact, I think a lot of people would take the list of evidence you've presented and draw the opposite conclusion that you have -- ie, that with the list you've provided, the lab leak is the likeliest conclusion.
Just to reiterate, I'm not suggesting that circumstantial evidence _does_ prove anything, I'm only making the point that circumstantial evidence successfully convinces a large number of people.
The fact that we lack so much data to support zoonosis when compared to the two previous coronavirus outbreak really stands out.
We are missing:
- an intermediate host being identified. Something that was identified within months for SARS and MERS. - Lack of non human mtDNA reads - Missing point mutations as the virus adapts towards humans. - Explanation on how the virus binds better toward human ACE2 than any other animal species. - Separate spillover events
And the list goes on, it's honestly shocking