The company isn't trying to optimize for best use of your time individually or to make you happy. They are trying to get some kind of result. And it very well may be worth inconveniencing and annoying higher performers to improve the performance of lower performers to achieve the result they want.
I got into management because I like solving problems and I reached a point where solving purely technical problems is no longer what it takes to actually drive a product forward and improve things. The problems I try to solve now are more organizational so that dev teams can actually reach that creative state where they are talking with the customer directly and engaged in the overall process. I'm an introvert. The face time and accolades are draining, but it's important work that you've got to be in a leadership position to take on effectively.
So your management wasn't doing their job? They're supposed to know who's working and who isn't regardless of what rituals are practiced.