How diverse was the nation that could enjoy the 1st amendment when it was passed compared to now? It is perhaps more a retrospective justification that would need data to support it.
America was if anything less diverse then than now. We've had many large periods of emigration since then. And that combined with the challenges with new technology tells me the first amendment is more important than ever.
Do you have any supporting data for that view or, rather, what might convince of the opposite of your view?
Give me some authoritative statistics that show otherwise.