Ockham's razor says my scenario is more likely.
Ockham's razor says my scenario is more likely.
The one I'm most familiar with is of the integration of mitochondria into eukaryotic cells. My understanding is that all mitochondria seem to trace to a common ancestor, which would suggest that this mutation appeared once, and was so overwhelmingly energetically advantageous that all eukaryotic life descended from that single individual.
(There are non-mitochondrial life forms, including prokaryotic bacteria. But so far as I'm aware every complex multicellular life form, and quite a few unicellular ones, are all prokaryotes.)
That's not the point I'm emphasizing here. It's the overwhelming metabolic advantage afforded by mitochondrial ATP respiration.
Of that, it seems only one variant has survived. It either emerged only once, or out-competed all prior and subsequent emergences.