Small reactors won't be economical if they take that many people to run.
Also, naval reactors aren't small. Aircraft carriers have two 250 MW (700 MW thermal) reactors. That is a respectable power plant and much larger than proposed modular reactors.
What are the numbers? What’s the TCO difference to similar systems without atmospheric carbon emissions?
The reasons are not simply refueling concerns, although that is a factor. The boats still need to refuel the humans onboard, ie. food supplies and occasionally munitions.
The reactor powers the boat using less mass than a typical diesel-electric, is more quiet, and can remain underwater for an entire deployment if necessary - something that's simply not possible with other power generation methods.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Virginia-class_submarine#:~:te....
To be absolutely pedantic not all US navy reactors are on submarines. They also power surface ships with them.
The question is “What are the numbers?”
Clearly the navy uses nukes due to advantageous performance characteristics. What are the numbers that a civilian small nuke must make to be viable?
Personally, I’m bullish on the companies in the micro reactor space that have minimal site construction. I’m less bullish on Oklo, given that their application had some glaring omissions and got denied an NRC license.
Everything is relative - but there's vastly more nuclear powered submarines than aircraft carriers. The Virginia Class, for example, is powered by a single 30MW reactor[1].
The article states these "microreactors" will range from 15MW to 100MW.
The "Nukes" in the Navy are highly trained, yes, but a military environment is going to be far rougher than anything privately managed for land-side power generation.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Virginia-class_submarine#:~:te....
The military has demonstrated you can easily maintain and operate them with a handful of 18 to 22 year olds.
No, they haven’t. Military reactors aren’t run by relatively junior enlisted personnel alone.
Like, this sudden optimism concerning nuclear power is a bit worrying. Lowest bidder building small plants everywhere. What a nightmare ...
I really don't get where all this trust for the competence of others comes from.
And now we are supposed to put small ones kinda everywhere where incompetent morons or terrorist can blow them up?
I don't think it's fair to think so little of the Nuclear Regulatory Commission. They have standards. I don't think it's reasonable to assume they will give up their standards of safety.
No one's said "we" are "supposed to put small ones kinda everywhere." This one's being installed at a military base. It should have adequate security.
The U.S. nuclear power industry has been producing energy for 66 years without a single fatality to a member of the general public.
> And now we are supposed to put small ones kinda everywhere where incompetent morons or terrorist can blow them up?
I'm pretty sure that a major military base in the middle of the Alaskan Interior has reasonably good security.
I'd rather have a plant that might spew poison than one that will definitely spew poison.