I want people to be able to easily contribute so they don't give up and just go back to GitHub. OAuth with a GitHub access level solves this, full stop.
A proper federation protocol is correct and the right option long term but there is no need to knock what actually works right this moment. Doing the right option often takes far longer than is ideal.
The point is to allow people not using GitHub to contribute easily.
OAuth and ForgeFed solve different, though related, problems.
Besides, I want to stay more or less independent from 3rd party services, particularly I'm bothered by the need to explicitly register an OAuth client. AP has a much better flow in that regard, services can interoperate without a given permission to do so.