incidentally, this isn't far off from how the human brain is believed to work (at least with long term memories).
https://news.northwestern.edu/stories/2012/09/your-memory-is...
incidentally, this isn't far off from how the human brain is believed to work (at least with long term memories).
https://news.northwestern.edu/stories/2012/09/your-memory-is...
Not as literal words printed somewhere in our mind it isn't. This is more akin to things like the funnel transformer. [0] Nevermind that we hardly understand how our minds actually work.
It's always funny to me when people on online forums confidently proclaim to know what cognition and thinking is all about and that furthermore it can be reduced to symbol shuffling on computers. No one has any clue how to make computers intelligent and anyone that claims to know is either doing marketing for some "AI" company or thoroughly confused about what counts as biological intelligence.
But that's probably reading a little too deeply and seriously into what I said.
Yes, but we have some informed theories.
Nobody knew how physics works at Newton's time either, but they did know enough to model to satisifcation lots of phenomena like ballistics...
>Did you know your gut is directly connected with cognition?
Well, it is widely reported even in pop-science articles for several decades!
>No one has any clue how to make computers intelligent
For not having "any clue", sure the LLM guys did quite well in getting some of the way to the goalposts...
Not to say all brain-gut axis data is irrelevant, but, as with almost all of biology, the effect sizes of observables anyone typically cares about are pretty small.
However, the visual system in rodents is probably the best data source we have that maps to any formal theory right now, along with temporal difference learning and RL in neuroscience.
> No one knows how the brain works
You sound very hostile, but I think OP agrees with you.
And I'm not sure why you're trying to dunk on them here. Perhaps at a high level the approach is very similar, even if the mechanics are very different. Would you scoff at someone saying "the robot moved its arm" and say "Ha! Robots don't have muscles, and humans don't have batteries! It's totally different!"?
It builds off previous histories and theories of technology which debunk the notion of "neutral" technology. Humans are very much influenced and inspired by doing things because of the technology they have at-hand.
Great example is looking at the most common mechanical models of the human heart. The original models for the heart describe it as a system of "pumps" because it was designed right during the height of the end of the industrial revolution, when the technology at the time were big mechanical pumps and machinery. So, the abstract model of the heart as a pump was born and used, not because necessarily its an "accurate" model but mainly because the terminology made sense to people at the time. Nowadays this model is criticised for a lot of reasons.
Cognitive science suffers from a lot of assumptions which may have been indirectly influenced by computer science (afterall, you're a researcher coming in at a time when you have these powerful machines that could crunch data. Well surely then you'll need to model the brain in a binary and computer-readable format).