This is effectively the science based method, since it can be tracked to a, perhaps, 'plausible' mechanism (although often now lean towards more 'intriguing' than parsimonious, especially if published somewhere like Nature)
Evidence based medicine has other faults. One subfield is meta-analysis, which looks for very solid observations that are reproducible, but often lacks the complicated modeling that may be necessary to see any highly conditional effects. So the findings tend to be real, but boring and often "well-known". It is however, a good way to check if the "well-known" observations in the literature are reproducible.