Hacker News Reader

As a physicist, it might just be my layman's impression, but it does seem like economics people are just putting a list of points in Excel, no error bars or anything. I don't think I've ever seen some error propagation stuff in some Economics calculation.

View on HN

As a physicist, I think you probably don’t have enough experience with economics research. (Which is fine! It’s not your field!)

Quantification of uncertainty is bread and butter for us! Criticize the field fo relying on null hypothesis significance testing, not for failing to provide measures of uncertainty!!

I've seen errors being considered while fitting a model, but not in the source data or when using the fitted data in another calculation.

But yeah, I hope it's just a simplification for laymen like me. But the fact that apparently there weren't errors bars in a dataset so important such as population estimatives doesn't give me the right impression

They care enough to p-hack [0] though

[0] https://sciencessociales.uottawa.ca/economics/sites/socialsc...

Reply on news.ycombinator.com