To me, that's what's most troubling about this: employers have the ability to strike now, while the iron is hot. If enough big employers can establish this as a standard practice, then pretty soon it becomes procedural. (Like the background check, the drug test, and other procedures that BigCo routinely uses in hiring practices).
In a perfect world, sure, you'd love to be able to walk away from a job offer and say "Well, I wouldn't want to work for any company that subjects me to this...so sayonara, suckers!" But a) vanishingly few people are in a position to do that, and b) there's a real danger that this practice becomes so widespread as to be unavoidable.
While I do think the current situation is being blown out of proportion, I think the potential danger is very real.
For instance, someone named John Smith might rename his FB profile "Johnny S." This tactic allows our hypothetical Mr. Smith to dodge search engine results for his full name. It wouldn't protect him from having to hand over his password, but at least it keeps all those photos of his brandishing red Solo cups out of employers' SERPs. (Also, with the right privacy settings in place, it keeps him from being searchable on Facebook by someone who's not a friend).
If the password-handover procedure actually does become standard, then yes, I'd imagine we'd see the rise of dummy profiles and other countermeasures.
Employers should not request access to candidates' social media outlets, just as they do not request to spend a weekend with me to observe my habits. Candidates, on the other hand, need to ensure their online presence is something they are proud of (and happy to defend) if seen by friends, parents, clerics and potential employers, IMHO.
The problem is that this is difficult, especially for younger people.
I've had various online aliases over the years, most of which have been abandoned because they no longer reflect me at all.
Let's say you were 16-18 and naive and got roped into some extreme political or religious cult group (this didn't happen to me btw). You might post all kinds of things and at the time you would probably be totally convinced that these were things you would be happy to share forever.
Basically, we need to tell kids "don't post anything online under your real name unless you would be happy to tattoo it onto your forehead"
And even that's probably not enough. Look at all the people who regret tatoos they've gotten. We're simply not very good at predicting how our lives or perspectives may change over time.
The guideline that I came up with is "don't post anything, anywhere, that you wouldn't be comfortable seeing on the front page of the newspaper".
Now all I have to do is keep drumming that message into him for the next three years.
Of course, there is the problem of people tagging you in Facebook that you can never un-tag.
You would only really need this to become procedure at one large company (say wallmart) to set a precedent that others will follow.