I used to think hydrogen was extremely safe. It’s super light right, so it should quickly vent away if there’s a leak? Then a hydrogen gas station nearby exploded. Didn’t look like it was very airtight to me, but somehow enough gas collected for a big explosion.
It’s extremely hard to prevent hydrogen leaks. The cause of the explosion was a fitting that wasn’t tightened to just perfectly the right torque. Supposedly the procedure to fix this is to have every fitting double checked by a second person. Doesn’t sound inherently safe to me.
There’s no warning if there’s a hydrogen leak. There’s no smell or visible gas.
The right mixture of hydrogen and air will practically self ignite. There was no source of fire at the gas station. The tiniest invisible spark can set it off.
I was also surprised by how loud the explosion was. The explosion is fast. It will rip things apart. On the positive side, it’s over very quickly. You’re not going to have a lingering fire from fuel that has sprayed everywhere like with Kerosene.
I think hydrogen CAN become perfectly safe with the right engineering. I think the solution will be that every single piece of tube or valve that has hydrogen flowing through it needs a double tubing around it with active ventilation, and sensors where it vents out to check that it has the expected air flow and no hydrogen gas is detected.
But inherently safe? No way