There's a very strong urge to believe that the brain "tunes" into some kind of non-meatspace realm (spiritual, quantum, etc.)
Fairly sure that it'll turn out that it just depends on the massive complexity of neuron/synapse connections, though.
But then you think of concepts like 'group psyche', and twins that are separated from birth but share the same thoughts/feelings over a distance...
Hopefully science will get to the bottom of it soon :)