This seems like a pretty bizarre framing. A police officer with a history of filing fraudulent reports or committing perjury should not still be a police officer.
This seems like a pretty bizarre framing. A police officer with a history of filing fraudulent reports or committing perjury should not still be a police officer.
It’s just a misdemeanor in many states so the DA can indict them without a grand jury! This is important because DAs use felony charges to pardon cops and launder it through a grand jury (we all remember the Buffalo NY cops that pushed the 75 year old man to the ground and left him bleeding from the head — cops charged with felony but GJ refused to indict, it can’t be proved but it’s obvious the DA sandbagged it).
But DAs almost never charge cops with anything, even the so-called progressive ones in the bluest states files a few token indictments against the a few token cops and then went back to business as usual.
If police are actually subject to the same system as the rest of us it will work, but DAs have pretty much always refused to do it.
It district attorney's started prosecuting cops, the system would crumble and come to a fast halt. There is no credibility in court and the charade continues.
There are a ton of interests at play, and yes, voting a certain way might help, but reforming a corrupt system is definitely not as simple as "we just vote for the other guy this time".
Of course not. But do you see how that DA or PA are disincentivized to take on the police?
I don't see how to elect someone who doesn't have the same incentive with regard to the police. The fact that the disincentive to take on the police is such a fundamental part of how the job works is precisely why I don't think the problem can be solved by just electing a different DA; the system itself needs to be changed, and that requires a lot of coordination across multiple fronts. Voting for different people is necessary for that sort of change but not nearly sufficient, which is why I think that saying it's purely the fault of voters for electing the wrong people is a gross oversimplification.
The desire and laws written to do this sort of thing come from lobbying organizations like ALEC [0][1][2]. This and other similar organizations basically write "model laws" and hand them to legislators to pass. That's why all the "red" states suddenly decided to outlaw trans people at the same time.
They dodge lobbying oversight laws by having legislators become "members" of their club.
0 - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_Legislative_Exchange_...
1 - https://www.alecexposed.org/wiki/ALEC_Exposed
2 - https://www.commoncause.org/our-work/money-influence/alec/
Having studied thousands of police reports, what is almost worse than testilying is that most reports are works of fiction. And the reports are what gets the defendants into court in the first place. Testilying only matters if an officer takes the stand, and an officer often only takes the stand in a trial. And 99% of criminal cases are resolved by plea before trial in the USA because a defendant does not want to risk a trial where the officer can lie and send them away for decades.
As such, their punishment should be even harsher, and tolerance for their lies should be even lower.
What's the first step toward implementing this system? What actions can be taken to get to that from where we are?
The police are not going to arrest the police. The DAs are not going to prosecute the police (who they generally regard as the "same team").
The system as designed and currently operating is broken and intentionally unfair and unjust. How do we go about replacing or fixing it?
This is only the right solution on paper. Not in reality, sadly.
The key is they have to be completely different career systems, where they don't fraternize or socialize with each other, and you'd probably have to make it somewhat antagonistic culturally so they don't end up doing something similar.
Which is why it has to be a different organization. Internal affairs is a systematic failure probably because it's within the same organizational tree as everyone else. It's really hard to incentivize people to do the 'right thing' when the incentives make it career suicide to do the right thing because you'll become a dangerous pariah as soon as you do.
Also to start I'd start with actions in court / evidence, not in the field until that organization starts running out of those actions to enforce because they've installed enough fear in the police system. That way the police can never have the cultural excuse to do their crap because 'their life is in risk and it's a split second decision' because your lying on boring safe paperwork and court where you have plenty of time to think about your actions, and over %50 of this will probably be lawyers actions too.
What is the first steps? Probably allying in blue states with anti-police movements and working with them in lobbying for a state enforcement arm that enforces specifically against unjust plea deals, testilying, withholding exculpatory evidence and focusing on prosecutors with out of the norm high conviction rates first. You'd also have to make it pay as well as private, which will also be hard. A wealthy state like california can fund such a thing, and it would probably be small, like 40 lawyers & their support staff, and be crazy effective. Unjust plea deals will probably be last politically if it is at all possible because the system will scream about it will screech to a halt and to address that is a much bigger issue.
Obviously there are risks to opening up the floodgates to private criminal prosecution, so you need restrictions and checks to avoid abuse by the wealthy and powerful. However, in some sense, the wealthy and powerful can already do that in the current system via access to the DAs, so it is not as much of a risk increase as it would seem.
The key here is figuring out a robust set of restrictions. Just to get ahead of the responses, I do not claim to have a comprehensive solution, so there is no point quibbling with me about how my proposal is incomplete. Take the problems you point out as areas of improvement and think about how they could be solved.
They should. Instead the system protects itself by insisting that secrecy must be maintained to preserve public trust. That's the reason they give for making judicial complaints so secret that you can't even subpoena judicial complaints to show a pattern of bias or misconduct by a judge.
if you want accountability, reduce the number of policing jobs to some number lower than the number of people who want to be police.
But the most important factor you didn’t raise is the increasing corporate funding of police [1].
[1] https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2020/jun/18/police-found...
maybe, maybe not
you would definitely open up the profession to all the people who consider themselves honest, and thus who have avoided a career in policing, which is rife in corruption, rewards corruption, and penalizes honesty
and let's be honest, it pays a TON for what isn't even close to one of the most dangerous professions, so neither pay nor danger are what keeps smart, honest people away
currently, most such people would avoid it because of the culture (particularly the culture of corruption), and bad police don't want and, indeed, deter such people from joining their ranks
> bad cops don't keep their jobs because they have a powerful union
almost universally, they do: the union literally prevents firing most bad police officers
I’m in total agreement though that if a police officer is found to have lied under oath, in statement, or report - they’re done. Same as one who discharges their firearm outside of a hostage/terrorist/school-shooting. Gunning down civilians, whatever their crime, is murder. Shooting someone because they are running and you can’t run fast - is murder.
The report found him guilty of the beating and noted his testilying. I think he was given a few days suspension for this. No criminal charges, obviously.
In another case, I told a friend to investigate the background of the lead detective against him. When we ran his file we found he had already been fired from the police department for using the computer system to change the upcoming court dates for another officer so he would miss court and not testify against a friend of the detective who had been pulled over for a suspected DUI.
I always use FOIA to access the police department records during pre-trial for defendants. The prosecutors are supposed to supply useful information like this to the defense, but I've never known it to happen without some prodding.
But they're paying union members, too!
Should be convict or ex-convict.