DEA Filing Defends Firing ‘Outstanding’ Special Agent for Using CBD
documentcloud.org
documentcloud.org
"Mr Armour understood...that CBD products containing no more than 0.3 percent of THC are legal hemp [and not marijuana]"
However, it looks like one of the CBD products he used were advertised as below the legal limit was not. But part of the problem identified is that the law identifies a threshold but not necessarily a required confidence against that threshold because it was close.
"Mr Armour provided what remained of the three CBD products and asked them to be tested...DEA's chemical analysis showed that two CBD products were legal...chemical analysis of [the third CBD product] measured THC above the 0.3 percent legal limit, even though that analysis was unable to establish whether THC was above the legal limit to a scientific degree of certainty with 95 percent confidence"
It also says that he assumed the risk because "he also understood that the FDA does not regulate CBD products".
So from the legal analysis there are two interesting points to me
1. He can argue that all of the CBD products he took were below the legal limit within a margin of error (burden of proof and all that) 2. Since he took legal products (assuming #1 holds) that the threshold for the urinary analysis is incorrect.
But I'm also not sure where the line is if you can take enough of a legal substance to violate a limit. For example, what if I drank enough orange juice (ABV in the ~0.2-~0.7% range) to get above a DUI limit? I assume I'm still legally culpable. What is the recourse though if somebody dumped some vodka in my orange juice before I bought from the store. There's certainly some recourse against the orange juice supplier since it is a controlled substance.
More of an interesting thought experiment, playing devils advocate here. Maybe this will actually spark something in changing definitions though. When I got my security clearance they basically said "we don't want to deal with the legal distinction between CBD products and marijuana products, so just don't touch any of it"
If it ever gets legalized nationally, this will have to be dealt with. I cannot imagine an employer firing someone for using alcohol or tobacco for example
Alaska Airlines will do just that. Source: any of their job postings, as they won't even hire tobacco users. But if they find out after hiring, you can guess the probable outcome.
They don't get to "own your life" but I don't feel its unreasonable to hold them to a standard higher than the average citizen in our society.
At the very least, he knew the stakes well ahead of time, and he knew it was his responsibility to make sure he didn’t get THC in his blood. As a drug cop, it would be strange for him not to understand that hemp products still contain some amount of THC. And although the firing decision only relied on the drug test, the evidence shows that he did in fact procure and use “CBD” products that were above the legal limit for THC content—and thus broke the laws it’s his job to enforce.
“I swear, officer, I didn’t know what it was!” doesn’t work for anybody else, so I have a hard time accepting that it should work for the elite cop whose job it is to know better.
the dude was fired for possessing and using a substance which is harmless, but still disallowed by bureaucrats
While they might not legally own your life, the decisions they make substaintially impact your ability to live. The current workforce system is designed to protect them, not you.