SJ said a lot of things. There is nothing courageous about cannibalizing an iPod that had an average selling price of $200 and a much smaller market with a phone that is three times more expensive
Cannibalising a public company's most successful product and profit source is extremely risky, especially for management. There is a reason this is so rare. It goes against many of our ingrained behaviours as humans.
So I don't think it's as obvious as you make out.
That means even then, the phone market was 1 billion devices a year. That was a much larger market than the stand alone music player market.
It was also clear that’s where the market was headed. Phone makers were already starting to sell music capable phones