Or, possibly more apropos to your example, “how do I know my medical debt relief payment goes to someone who truly Deserves It because of bad luck and not someone whose poor diet and exercise habits lead to their stroke?”
The system is designed to turn bad choices into bad luck - and the opposite - and to pass moral judgements on those who need help. Reject the framing and help people; most are good and deserving.
The thing I specifically caveated was people making bad financial decisions on their own. Sure, maybe giving an 18 year old $5k credit limit is not a smart thing on the creditor's part, but not everyone financing retail therapy sessions via credit is an 18 year old. The whole 30 thousandaire outspending their earnings for FOMO or keeping up with the Joneses or whatever does not seem like something we need to bail out.
I think we worry too much about what if undeserving people receive help. Most people are good people who just got caught out on something and could use some help getting themselves out of some goddamn 25% interest craziness.
GP is referring to credit card debt, not medical debt.
You've spun into something it's not to make a point. Which I'm still not sure what it is
Which is still a valid point. Don’t give cash to homeless people.
i think this confusion is something holding back progress on homelessness.
I have on multiple occasions helped someone out that was facing some very difficult decisions because of not having a place to stay. People that are not addicts can be put in making choices that they would never even consider in a normal situation, but we faced with sleeping in a car/street/public shelter, those choices suddenly start to look more acceptable. Even more so if you have kids.
Sorry, I meant “you” in the general sense, not you personally.
> The view you take sounds like you've been privileged
Stuff it with the personal comments.
> I have on multiple occasions helped someone out that was facing some very difficult decisions because of not having a place to stay.
I have as well. And in my experience, at least with street people, it’s much better to give them bottled water and food than to give them cash. If it’s a family member or someone you actually know, that’s a completely different situation than what most people (not you, to be clear!) are talking about when they say “don't give cash to homeless people”.
>Stuff it with the personal comments.
s/privileged/(fortunate|lucky)/
Wasn't meant to be an aggressive comment. A poor choice of words.
The only thing I’m unclear on is how to avoid the predatory aspect. I’d assume that part of the usury terms of these kinds of loans is a response to such small amounts. Just paying the hourly cost of dealing with the transaction could put a $200 dollar loan into 5% territory without taking into account any risk profile.
I’d be intereted in running experiments similar to cash giving charities. Measure how much a $2000 line of credit does to improve lives (hopefully without making them worse).
I get what you're saying but if you've ever gotten to "I now have enough credit card debt for it to be A Problem", the baseline level of stress in your entire life gets pretty high. That doesn't mean that suddenly everyone has "learned their lesson forever", but especially for stuff like "I was bad at personal finance in my 20s, and now I am better but the debt is still around and a problem", helping people with that debt can just make somebody's life much better.
Nothing is guaranteed but if it were a family member and you had a way to clear out some stuff for pennies on the dollar, it feels like the right sort of thing to do.
Student loan debt is an entirely different thing though. I'm still on the fence about student loan forgiveness because I specifically stopped going to school because I did not want to take on the debt. It's a sensitive subject, and I am sympathetic to it. I'd be much more open to 0%, or partial payoff to reduce the obviously bloated amounts the schools are charging.
The thing I was implicitly thinking is that you might do that for somebody you care about, and ultimately things like debt forgiveness programs are also about giving compassion to people you might not know.