I only bite half to this argument.
If they really wanted to fight against credit card number theft, they would:
- Enforce pin payment everywhere around the world - Ban magnetic strip payment once for all - Enforce two factor authentication system for anything related to online payment.
They do not. Why ?
Because the fraud "real" cost is mainly thrown in the wild on the merchant that have to deal with their goods being sent and their payment being reverted.
It is a liability issue.
I am pretty sure that with a little law that, lets say, enforce Banks to reimburse their customers under 24h00 for a small fee, lets say 10$, in case of fraudulent transaction: This entire system of scam would fade away pretty quickly.
(Also keep in mind that it's often the same companies that do debit and credit cards. For example, I have debit cards in the Mastercard and Visa networks, but no credit cards. I assume most of the fraud prevention efforts benefit my debit cards as well.
Also that relying on a bunch of numbers alone is pretty sketchy. But I am choosing to interpret fraud more widely, than just card number theft. I am pretty sure card number theft is pretty low(er) in parts of the world where people pay with chip-and-pin, and don't use numbered cards.)
It seems that fraud protection is rather something that is necessary because fraud is so easy.