The problem with a police union is that management (i.e. Captains + & Commissioners) are part of the union.
It'd be like if Gary Bettman ran the NHLPA.
All the entertainment unions (IATSE, WGA, SAG, DGA, and I think even some athlete unions, etc), do not base their pay off of seniority and also don’t cap their pay. So higher skilled players can absolutely still negotiate terms and pay when accepting a job. The workers in these unions just have access to more protections.