Hacker News Reader

I'm sorry, but you're still tracking your 19 year old and calling them if they don't seem to be in class? They're an adult. If they haven't learned how to be responsible by now, then it's time you let them learn, possibly the hard way.

Having tracking capability in an emergency could be good. But my God, when do you expect them to be a fully functioning human if not by 19?

View on HN

You’re right, but I bet there’s a sorta defensible position by the parent—they’re footing a massive college education bill so their kid doesn’t go into debt.

Nope, still not a reason. The way you handle it, is you have the kid take out the loan. Then you pay off the amount if the semester was successfully completed. This provides them freedom and autonomy to learn and be responsible. It also provides them with credit history.

Usually universities mandate a "parental contribution" - but the idea of having the student borrow the money and immediately pay it back is interesting.

I wonder if the student would be able to get such a loan?

At least what I've seen in the US, there's no requirement for a parental contribution. There are some loans that require disclosure of parental assets to determine eligibility.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com