My comment is mostly about part 2 of this post, but wrt message ordering being a kafka "win" I'd raise the point that in the actual use case of "a consumer fails in some way to process the message" you can still end up with out of order processing of the consumer's input since you might want to dump them into a DLQ or something. The fact that the message isn't reappended to the topic by default for processing is kind of an academic point no?
Unrelatedly, I've been looking at Pulsar lately. Anyone have experience with Pulsar and either RMQ/Kafka want to throw out some opinions from having tried both?