This is the first time I see this definition of intelligence.
My first impression is that this is a relevant aspect of intelligence, but very far from "all about". (other aspects being things like "abstract thought", world knowledge, agency, ...)
> That latter impulse resigns the whole field to cheap mimicry
AIs are inherently non-human intelligence. (I like the shoggoth-comparison [1]). AI companies go to great length to make them behave more human-like. If you look at earlier AIs (e.g. when they play games against humans), you will find that human experts (e.g. the people they play against) they will often note, that the AI behaves very unhuman and un-understandable in certain aspects (e.g. they make a move that seems utter non-sense at first, but will be very important 40 moves latter in the game). (I should note, that the opposite is true as well: sometimes the AI surprises the expert by exhibiting very human-like behavior)