It doesn't mean that the village idiot gets a gun to threaten and start fights with.
(For why, understand that the framers themselves understood that a constitution cannot contain its own undoing, i.e. contain clauses that would allow the people to lawfully dismantle their own government. 2A interpretations that hinge on the individual’s right to overthrow a hypothetically tyrannical federal government fly in the face of this.)
~ Henry Flanders 1860 https://twitter.com/MorosKostas/status/1645290303832858627
> Some tyrannical governments resort to disarming the people, and making it an offence to keep arms, or participate in military parades. In all countries where despots rule with standing armies, the people are not allowed to keep guns and other warlike weapons.
~ Joseph Bartlett Burleigh 1852 https://twitter.com/MorosKostas/status/1645292036277547009
> This provision is so plainly proper that its propriety need not be argued. It will be sufficient to contrast it with the practice of despotic governments, who, while they maintain large standing armies, at all times subservient to their pleasure, will not allow arms in the hands of the common people.
~ Rev. Daniel Parker 1848 https://twitter.com/MorosKostas/status/1645292053784559616
> Right to Bear Arms - To deny the right of citizens to bear arms is a means employed by despotic rulers to enforce arbitrary government. Without such clause, ambitious men might, by the aid of the regular army, overthrow the liberties of the people.
~ Albert E Maltby 1909 https://twitter.com/MorosKostas/status/1645293391234863105
A long thread of many sources: https://threadreaderapp.com/thread/1645290263299117056
Put another way: someone equally interested in frivolous arguments about the 1A could surely dig up “common sense” opinions from the 19th century about how blasphemy, obscenity, &c. are all reasonably excluded from the franchise. But that doesn’t make them correct.
This is why the Bruen opinion is so great. It uses the historical understanding approach. Which should be applied to the 1A as well.
Here's an example of the conservative AEI making essentially the same point[1]: that a constitutionally framed democratic sovereign cannot enshrine a right of revolution, even if the individual right of revolution is an inalienable one. This is basic political theory, whether you choose to take a historical approach or not.
[1]: https://www.aei.org/articles/is-there-an-american-right-of-r...
https://www.heritage.org/the-essential-second-amendment/the-...