This law now makes it illegal for anyone that can only provide $19/hour of economic revenue from working at a fast food restaurant.
This law now makes it illegal for anyone that can only provide $19/hour of economic revenue from working at a fast food restaurant.
For starters it's nonsensical.
Don't get me started with the jargon. "Economic revenue?" "Illegal?"
While I don't think you deserve to get downvoted for such nonsense, because maybe it is interesting for someone to explore the premise of what you're actually saying, even if you are saying it extremely poorly, I am at least trying to explain for you personally why a normal person will read this and think, "What is this guy talking about?"
So if I want to hire person A, but person A is only able to do work that would drive $18 in revenue for me, then I won't hire them at $20 because I will lose money.
If I were to hire them at $18 I would at least be neutral, and maybe I could work to get their skills up to the point where they are delivering more than $18, and I am now positive. Maybe they do well enough for me to increase their pay over time.
But I cannot do that with this new law. I'm banned from paying them $18. They simply will never work for me, or maybe anyone.
I would encourage you to work harder as a business owner to pay a living wage, if you so choose to be a business owner who requires labor.
Correct. Which is why a business offers a wage and the labor either accepts or rejects it.
Zero times have restaurants forced people to work. Exactly all times people have chosen to work, at an agreed upon wage.
Why do you think the government should get to decide for how much I'm willing to sell my labor?
Because government's role is to protect its citizens. My apologies if this government is not suitable to you, you may have to relocate if a representative democratic outcome is not to your liking. The evidence is incredibly clear workers need protections from business and capital in the current socioeconomic system, but you may disagree depending on your mental model.
We have opposing views, and that's okay.
I believe a government should only provide public goods (nonrivalous and nonexcludable). I believe the primary purpose of a government is to protect private property and provide a system for resolving disputes.
I believe that welfare should be left to private sector charity. I believe that when the government does it, it is akin to using legal violence to force others to give to your causes, which then robs them of the funds they would rather give to other causes.
What if the private property that the government is protecting was obtained (by ancestors) by “legal” violence to force others to give to your cause?
If the current, then it is the duty of the government to resolve the dispute and restore the private property.
If it was a former, then there is nothing to be done. The jurisdiction was dissolved, unless the current government recognizes it (but then of course the jurisdiction would not be dissolved).
So if you fall along the lines that taxation is theft, who do you expect to protect your property if you're not paying anyone to do so? And why should I pay taxes so that the government can protect your property?
I'd happily allow the government to prevent the exploitation of its citizens, but I don't believe that voluntary transactions are exploitation. Why would I want the government to prohibit me from selling my labor at the price I choose?
> So if you fall along the lines that taxation is theft, who do you expect to protect your property if you're not paying anyone to do so? And why should I pay taxes so that the government can protect your property?
Taxation isn't theft when it is utilized to pay for public goods. It becomes akin to theft when my money is taken to be redistributed to folks in such a way I can't consume (non public good).
Currently I have to pay nearly $2k/year in county tax for other people's children to go to daycare. Why on earth am I paying for that? I pay $2k/month per child to send them to daycare and get $0 of the $2k I send to others back to spend on my own children. That is theft.
It is not a public good.
Welfare is not a public good, and therefore we should not use the government to pursue it.
Simple, but not actually true.
A typical fast food establishment. Say Chikfila will clear 15k of revenue on a typical slow night. On a good night easily 25k.
An 8 hour shift at $20 an hour is $160. You need to have 5 people in the kitchen and 6-7 out front bagging and taking orders. 12*160 = 1920
Typically wages are your most expensive line item.
So essentially everyone on HN is arguing over $500 a night from revenue that is already hitting 80% profit.
If anything the minimum wage should be $30.
It's almost like techies should stay in their lane and stop talking about economics they know nothing about.
What about the risk that the entrepreneur took in terms of their capital to open the franchise? Are they not due compensation?
Minimum wage requirements do several things:
- Make those who cannot deliver $x/hr in revenue permanently unemployed
- Drive up costs for consumers
Sure, those who keep their jobs are better off, but that doesn't offset the negatives imo.
Maybe the restaurants will eat the losses by not passing on costs to remain competitive, but we're already in a massive inflation cycle, so it wouldn't be hard for them to raise rates while blaming the law. But how many businesses needed to be driven to insolvency for your policy to determine minimum wage is at last sufficiently high?
How far are you willing to quantify "where I live" geographically? Is it just CA? Should OR, AZ, NV all have the same policy? What about Mexico?
Why $20? Why not $22? Why not $1876436?
> The local government expects a certain amount of tax revenue from wages and since you're not willing to pay that cost of doing business you can go elsewhere.
The government could just as well increase sales tax? Why choose a policy that increases unemployment and drives out tax-paying inhabitants?
If you can't handle that you're too poor for us.
1. Labor is only ~a third of costs. [1]
2. A slow day at Chick-fil-a would average like 25 people per hour (more during meals, less in between), averaging $10 per person. So $2k per 8 hour shift.
With a waaaaaay bigger dinning room too.....for 100 in-store orders per hour.
I lived in a wealthy suburb with only 1 of them so we had insane rushes. At times all 4 registers would have lines and the drive thru would be going out the parking lot. In that hour the rate of orders could go over 200 an hour and you're talking families of 4 or more.
They are supposed to get your order bagged in under 2 minutes (yellow) or 5 minutes (red). If something hits red it's because it's still in the fryer but it's not so bad cause it's the freshest when you get it.
So you acknowledge your experience is just a special case? This law covers all of California, not just your particular suburb. So unless you think that only wealthy people deserves fast food I don't see what point you are making.
No, it doesn’t.
It makes it less likely that they would be employed to, but there is no law against employing people at an economic loss, and employers often do this (though they don’t tend to continue doing it when they realize that they are; but that’s their choice, not a legal mandate.)
The argument assumes (as naive economic arguments often do) perfect information on the part of all participants (particularly, that employers know both the maximum economic utility an employee will provide and the effect of wage on their productivity without error), which while a standard component of rational choice theory is also a component that is known not to match the real world at all, being wildly wrong for many purposes.