But that's not it. Windows 7 still works, in fact, all Windows versions still work if you still have the hardware (or VM) for it. It is just that upgrades from Windows 7/8 are not free anymore. But that's normal, major upgrades are rarely free. The free Windows 10 to 11 (previously 7/8 to 10) path is the exception here, because Microsoft really want as many people as possible to essentially beta test the latest version of Windows.
It’s a horrific, intrinsically anti-user idea that should be loudly and aggressively smothered every time it rears its ugly head.
There is no version of reality where OS-as-a-service does not become a n irreversible hostage situation, leaving users at the mercy of “line go up” corporate self-enrichment. We’re practically there already.
Look at the trajectory of IoT products. Even if you pay extra for a product that is sold as no-subscription - like the PHILIPS Hue line for example - one day you will inevitably discover the hardware that you already paid for is being held hostage until you accept the new Terms of Service and pay a subscription fee.
This isn’t hyperbole - it has already happened dozens, even hundreds of times.
OS-aaS is a cute idea for a world where the free market is working correctly, bolstered by strong consumer protections and effective enforcement of regulations.
There must be a line.
Imagine if I get screwed by Microsoft. I can always install Linux or some other OS on my PC.
With mobile, even if I don't pay monthly for the OS, after a few years, the OEM discontinues support and the only option if some hacker didn't build a custom ROM for my specific device is to buy a new device or see my system slowly break down as apps drop support, and that's without considering security.
So we are already being "taken hostage" without an explicit subscription, and in a way that encourages throwing away perfectly good hardware and produce e-waste.
The locked down hardware is the real big problem. A paid OS subscription on an open hardware platform is bad, but a "free" OS on a closed platform is worse, because while you are hostage in both situations, in the former, you still have usable hardware.
IIRC Philips Hue supports zigbee, so you are not completely hostage. With an open zigbee controller, you still have working light bulbs, you can stop using Philips subscription software. Inconvenient, but you don't have to throw away your lightbulbs.
Or are we going to pay to be violated? And told to like it?
There's also a not-so-good incentive of the manufacturer not having to worry as much about QA because it's a given the fixes / maintenance is going to be paid by the subscribers. That is, no sense increasing quality if the lack there of doesn't effect margin and perhaps is even rationalized as justifying the subscription model.
I've used MS and Apple in the past, but both are privacy threats at this point. My next hardware update will be a made-for-Linux machine.
Shame on me already.
It is not that weird of an idea. As vendors of OS, must keep putting real effort in their products. And that isn't free. So either they can sell copy one time or then sell subscription.
Sad thing is that Windows has been extremely cheap for amount of use you can get out of single licence. Years of 24/7 use...