They didn't even bother using multiple passes to prompt better quality creative writing like "Write an outline for the story..." "Expand this outline focusing on improving style and tone..." "Here's a story written by an amateur writer. As a professional writer, give it a rewrite improving vocabulary, metaphor, and overall quality."
As with a lot of the LLM stuff I see these days, I have to wonder at how much of what's being measured is the capacity of the tool and how much the measurement of the capacity of its users.
I'd never imagine using a LLM zero shot in a single pass for any creative writing tasks, and measuring the inability to perform in suboptimal conditions isn't all that revealing or novel (pun intended).