"Human's don't just parrot what other people say, therefore we must be doing something more than what LLMs do, because an LLM only parrots the words that it is trained on. But an LLM is not truly intelligent because it is not doing what humans are doing—and because the LLM is not intelligent, all it is doing is parroting the training data."
Where in this line of reasoning is it proved that the mechanisms are different?
What if, instead, the conscious intelligence that differentiates humans from other animals is an emergent quality of language learning, specifically? Isn't there evidence that children that don't have access to language—deaf children who are not taught sign language, or feral children, or seriously neglected children—often cannot reason before they are taught language, and suffer from long-term cognitive impairment for having lacked language during their early development? Wouldn't this point to a fundamental linkage between language and human intelligence?