It might be true or it might not, but talking about it as if it's definitely true is simply wrong.
The combat explanation fits the evidence as well as anything else. Perhaps it's not proven to be true, but it's certainly not proven to be false.
> It might be true or it might not, but talking about it as if it's definitely true is simply wrong.
But you didn't.
> Your second is a non-sequitur.
How?
There is no evidence of the myth being true. There are no sources in history suggesting it.
It might be true. But there is no evidence that it is.
Proving it false is another matter.
> Medieval staircases were NOT built going clockwise for the defender’s advantage
and
> it’s not true.
Which seem like confident statements with no affirmative evidence to support them.
In fairness, their conclusion is more measured:
> So in conclusion: there’s no evidence for this claim and it also doesn’t make a lot of sense.
But that's not the headline they went with.
see also: Russell's teapot
We do not believe that maybe it is true this teapot exists, maybe not, simply because the initial hypothesis (that it is true in the first place) hasn't yet been falsified. If that were the case, I could make up a thousand improbable myths, and say they're all maybe true, maybe not, and we would have to treat them all as equally plausible until someone wastes their time trying to disprove all thousand, and then I could make up a thousand more.
That is why the burden of proof of truth lies with the person asserting the truth of a teapot/staircase belief
To add to your A vs. not-A problem, you are close to identifying the resolution, too: For an analogue in statistics, A = "this staircase explanation has sufficient evidence to say it is true", not-A = "this staircase explanation does not have sufficient evidence to conclude it is true". Not-A here is example of what is called the null hypothesis in statistics. The null hypothesis is the default.
It's an argument against believing without evidence, not for believing without evidence.
It's an argument against entertaining theories that have no evidence, against ignorant agnosticism towards any arbitrary theory
Then, since we agree that the claim has no evidence to support it, we assume it is false.
Therefore, we conclude, "it is true that staircases were built clockwise to advantage the defender".
I agree that the burden of proof lies upon the person that makes the claim. But that doesn't mean we assume the opposite of the claim must be true until they do. It means we assume ignorance.
So, a more correct statement would be: "In the absence of evidence of why the staircases were constructed, we do not know why they were constructed".
To say the absence of evidence proves the opposite of the claim is wrong.
> But that doesn't mean we assume the opposite of the claim must be true until they do. It means we assume ignorance.
Regardless of the wording, the gist is the same: we /don't/ assume ignorance, we treat the claim, like Russell's teapot [0], or any other unsupported claim, as false until such evidence arises, since there are an infinite number of unfalsifiable premises, and we neither want to, nor do, in practice, treat them all as maybe true, maybe not, forever.
tl;dr: As Russell's teapot [0] demonstrates, yes, there is a default, and that is that a thing is false unless sufficient evidence exists to believe otherwise. No, we don't treat all unfalsified (and unfalsifiable) hypotheses as unknown and assume ignorance.
In 1958, Russell elaborated on the analogy:
> "...nobody can prove that there is not between the Earth and Mars a china teapot revolving in an elliptical orbit, but nobody thinks this sufficiently likely to be taken into account in practice..."[0]
Replace 'teapot revolving in orbit' with 'truth to the staircase fighting myth' – hopefully you now see why it's ridiculous to entertain all hypotheses as equally likely without evidence.
Russell's teapot argument is about so-called unfalsifiable theories, not about all things.
That's just it – there isn't. There isn't any effective difference between "assume false" and "no evidence for it, so we assume false". The reason we assume it's false is tangential to the fact that we assume that both the teapot theory and the fighting staircase theory are false.
> Russell's teapot argument is about so-called unfalsifiable theories, not about all things
The point of Russell's teapot, as Russell explained, and I quoted, is that even though the teapot (like this myth) is neither proven nor disproven, we should, and do, treat it as false, because that is the default state until sufficient evidence arises.
It's an argument against entertaining theories that have no evidence, against ignorant agnosticism towards any arbitrary theory.
Either way, I think the fighting staircase theory, like the teapot theory, is not falsifiable, but anyone is free to show it is, by falsifying it.
Well, the next time I find myself in a melee battle within a castle and am deciding whether I should fight my way up the stairs, I'm going to draw a distinction between: "Is absolutely false", and "We don't know whether it was true or false", and I'm going to let someone else go up the stairs first...
This is your position, but it's not a position presented in the Wikipedia article.
> we should, and do, treat it unproven
Do you mean disproved here, rather than unproven? I think that when we know something has been neither proved nor disproved we should treat it as unproven (because it is unproven), but that does not mean we should assume that it is false.
It actually is, it's Russell's position! :) You claimed that before, and I corrected you then, so here, again for you, is the relevant part:
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37831693
Also, you forgot the rest of that! It was probably an honest mistake on your part, so I'll include the full context here, including the parts you missed, and hopefully you can address the whole thing now:
> That's just it – there isn't. There isn't any effective difference between "assume false" and "no evidence for it, so we assume false". The reason we assume it's false is tangential to the fact that we assume that both the teapot theory and the fighting staircase theory are false.
This is very unclear to me, but if what you mean is something like "There is no practical difference between supposing something to be false and supposing the thing to be so unlikely that it shouldn't be taken into account in one's decisions" I might agree with you - both that it is true and that something like it is present in the Wikipedia article - and we could go on from that point.
>The reason we assume it's false is tangential to the fact that we assume that both the teapot theory and the fighting staircase theory are false.
I'm not sure what the "it" is in the "it's" part of this sentence, so I can't respond to this part of your comment.
> This is very unclear to me, but if what you mean is something like "There is no practical difference between supposing something to be false and supposing the thing to be so unlikely that it shouldn't be taken into account in one's decisions" I might agree with you
Not sure what part of that is unclear to you, but feel free to ask clarifying questions. I did indeed phrase what I said correctly. Your phrasing is also correct. To tie the two together, it is as likely, with our currently-zero affirmative evidence, that the teapot exists, as it is, with our currently-zero affirmative evidence, that the fighting staircase theory is true. Thus, if you effectively treat the teapot's existence as false, you should also effectively treat the fighting staircase theory as false.
> > The reason we assume it's false is tangential to the fact that we assume that both the teapot theory and the fighting staircase theory are false.
> I'm not sure what the "it" is in the "it's" part of this sentence, so I can't respond to this part of your comment.
Again, you're always free to ask me questions if you don't understand something! In this case, "it" refers to the teapot theory and the fighting staircase theory, since the two are analogous here.
> by default, it is untrue
but instead that by default it is effectively untrue? And by that you mean that we can act in practical matters act as if it is untrue, even though we do not actually know whether that is the case?
Indeed, effectively untrue means untrue for all intents and purposes (including even seriously discussing), and both the teapot and the fighting staircase theory are equally: untrue, effectively untrue, practically untrue, and any other semantic game you wish to play around the word untrue, for the same reason as each other. They have an equal amount of evidence of their truth, after all.
That we should assume these things to be false, or merely effectively false?
> Indeed, effectively untrue means untrue for all intents and purposes (including even seriously discussing), and both the teapot and the fighting staircase theory are equally:
> - untrue,
> - effectively untrue,
> - practically untrue,
> - something we assume to be untrue,
> - and any other semantic game you wish to play around the word untrue,
> for the same reason as each other. They have an equal amount of evidence of their truth, after all :)
At this point, you seem to be coming up with new ways of wording that the teapot and fighting staircase theories are untrue, so if you come up with more, simply add them to the above 5 item list!
And just to be clear, I'm not claiming anything myself, merely examining and judging the claims of those who lend any credence to the totally unsupported teapot or fighting staircase theories, and pointing out that the results of that examination and judgement don't look good for 'em.
You could hold these two positions simultaneously without there being any contradiction:
* they are both equally untrue.
* they are both true
Because they both have zero truth, they are equally untrue, meaning an equal amount of untrue: zero in both cases.
Turns out there's no contradiction, and no truth to either!
Also, what if two contradictory propositions each have zero evidence, are they then both untrue?
It actually is! I even quoted it a couple times up in this thread :) Maybe you're confused over effectively true vs practically true vs true vs. etc, but that's just semantics, they all mean the same thing!
> Also, what if two contradictory propositions each have zero evidence, are they then both untrue?
It depends, can you give details (what are the specific propositions)? For example, Russell's teapot explains when the "contradiction" is between the teapot existing without evidence vs. not existing
You could argue that they could be treated as if they mean the same thing (in some limited scope), but that is different to them meaning the same thing, and, since such an argument is not presented in the Wikipedia page (rather, a contrary position is presented by Russell in the second quotation on that page[0]) you would have to make that argument yourself.
[0] He makes an explicit distinction between what he ought to call himself if being purely logical and what he practically is (an agnostic and an atheist, respectively).
I wonder if it's easier for right handed masons to build a staircase in a particular chirality. What percentage of modern staircases are built in a particular direction?
If the staircase happens to be on one side of the building, it would be better to orient it one way - based on how the windows would work - for example.
If the staircase is against another busy entryway - it might be better to have the stairs go one way or the other, etc
The ratio of staircases in Norman castles was more like 20:1 which is a ratio even more in need of a non-chance explanation; the greater numbers of anticlockwise staircases came later, when coincidentally or otherwise individual towers were less important to the overall defensive scheme
There are so many things that could bias this result. Maybe it's easier to craft in one direction. Perhaps, north of the equator, castles tended to be constructed in certain orientations, with the windowless stairwells tending towards one side versus another. Altogether, there is no reason to prefer the myth over any of those hypotheses--they each have no evidence.
There's got to be a reason, even if it was as simple as "it was arbitrarily chosen and then became standard practice."
There was an article here on HN a while ago talking about how the stupidly designed staircases were responsible for the Victorian trope of "falling down a staircase to your death."--the ones for servants were especially poorly designed.