> This is one of the best examples I know of how software patents can be good for competition.
Small companies and startups with products in the market (before existing incumbents have products) should be able to get software patents to defend their innovation.
Big companies should be able to have patents, but not use them against smaller players.
Patent trolls with no products in the market shouldn't be allowed to have patents.
Universities and university researchers should be able to have patents, but they should be forced to license at not-unreasonable terms to startups.
My thoughts on the matter, anyway. The point is to encourage innovation, especially by enabling small players bringing new stuff to market. Give them a small shield against the big incumbents.