It will be interesting to see how it compares to modern groups of people. I don't think having ancestors in a place 1700+ years ago gives you defacto claim to ownership either way though.
In the end, "legitimacy" of a group claiming exclusive access to a piece of land comes down to might-makes-right.
The other stuff is usually window dressing.
Makes for good grievance politics though, eh?
Sadly there are places in the world, a lot of them in Africa, where nobody can look beyond their superficial traits to classify criminals apart from their victims.