Final Fantasy XIII and XIII-2 have been released for both PS3 and Xbox 360. Maybe the game developers are starting to get the upper hand when it comes to contractual exclusives?
So it's basically a business case thing, and a matter of leverage. Big, successful studios - say, Rockstar, makers of GTA - have a very strong bargaining position, and they know they can sell lots of units on all platforms. Whereas a weaker developer might be happy to take a boatload of money for an exclusive, as it de-risks the development somewhat for them.