What's funny to me is how people can be so confident about astrophysics theories, when we're just a primitive race that hasn't even ventured beyond our own moon and fighting brutal wars over whose imaginary god is correct.
What's funny to me is how people can be so confident about astrophysics theories, when we're just a primitive race that hasn't even ventured beyond our own moon and fighting brutal wars over whose imaginary god is correct.
Since it's not seen or understood, we could say it's "dark" for brevity. And since it's clearly affecting gravity let's just say "matter" for short.
It's hard to say why only _some_ galaxies have their gravity modified without it being caused by some sort of substance.
It really hasn't. The same standard of evidence that would rule out modified gravity would also rule out dark matter.
This kind of a wordplay shell game is really bad for science
"Dark matter" comes from a group of observations that consistently suggest there is more mass in the universe than we can account for. The fact that we keep observing it is not the same thing as an explanation for the observations. There are also theories that try to explain dark matter! But the fact that people observe it is not a theory.
> That things fall towards the earth isn't a theory.
Actually, it is.
Any given object falling once is an observation. Noticing more than one thing falling consistently is a theory.
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=PbmJkMhmrVI&pp=ygUbZGFyayBtYXR...
Galaxy rotation curves are better explained by applying general relativity without the severely restrictive assumptions required in lambda cdm. You don't even need the full thing, just the first order linear approximation that allows for gravitational waves (and thus is causal), as Ludwig showed a few years ago. You need at least this because gravitational waves exist, and those cannot occur in the singular newtonian limit used mostly for convenience.
It doesn't take much to then question the need for dark matter as if it is compensating for poor models in one case, it probably is doing the same in others.
No they don't. Galaxies exhibit anomalous velocity curves according to existing gravitational theory as applied in a specific cosmological model. That's the observation. This could be explained by a halo of indivisible stuff or it could be explained by a misunderstanding of gravity or a different cosmological model.
I'm general, we should not explain observations in terms of speculative theories, because this carries a presumptive bias.
> The halos even perturb as expected in galaxy collisions.
They actually don't. Dark matter would explain part of the bullet cluster (lensing), but it can't explain the high collision velocities observed.
Our data doesn’t fit GR with the boundary conditions that make sense more locally. Positing a bunch of non-interacting mass/energy is closer to observations than doing nothing.
Calling it a placeholder seems honest, reasonable, and productive.
Getting pushy about WIMPs and stuff (which is deeply intertwined with the refusal to give up on supersymmetry because, careers) in a world where Michio Kaku is on TV talking about quantum computing and AI in a way that’s less scientific than Matt Gaetz yelling about UFOs on C-SPAN to distract from the child-trafficking charges is icky.
Especially when they're the same imaginary god[0].
Are you claiming that one group is less wrong about their fake deity than another? That's rich.