Is anyone actually comparing the bells and whistles on yahoo.com to the ones on google.com? The sites are like night and day.
Having a sparse homepage is not the reason why Google is winning today, or why Yahoo lost.
The sparse homepage is one of the main reasons I switched to Google way back in the day.
All my Google use is done with Firefox search bar.
Yes, clutter = slow, slow = I wouldn't use it.
I can't actually remember the last time I saw the home page outside a screenshot, I just use the chrome url bar search, which is about the limit i can currently imagine for a sparse search interface.