Lumia 900: Proof that competing directly against the iPhone is a bad idea?
extremetech.com
extremetech.com
On the other hand, I find it amusing picturing Nokia trying to conquer the "low-end" market. Not so long ago, it was still making the high-end phones, with LG and Samsung (of all companies!) trying to attack lower ranges...
I've worked with Nokia in the past, though, on their various attempts at an app market and trying to convince people that their Symbian OS and Maemo OS were going to take over the mobile market. They build great hardware and terrible software, but that's not their biggest problem. Their biggest problem is a Sony-like inability to get out of their own way. Every project they did had competing managers with competing agendas, and each initiative changed course so often that we gave up trying to predict or even understand where our next objectives would be.
Nokia is driven by committees and bean counters. There's no vision at the top. They spend all of their time and energy in search of market segments, and never get around to just building great products.
These phones aren't that great, but are cheap smartphones that are appealing to the feature-phone market.
Lumia 900 in terms of hardware and price is somewhere in the middle, and IMHO that's not a good place to be in, especially since these budget Android phones may be crappier, but are Androids nonetheless.
But yeah, I'd be interested to hear some mom-and-pop experiences with cheap Android phones.
Your headline: Lumia 900: Proof that competing directly against the iPhone is a bad idea?
Also, I'll reiterate that Extreme Tech has worse journalism than Gizmodo.
It's more like comparing a well optioned Toyota Camry to a base BMW 5 series.
There has to be a market for a Ferrari-like phone, so where is it?
Except you can get a license to side-load your own WP7 apps without paying the developer fee. It's a compromise, sure, but on the other hand, it's a compromise. The team who made a jailbreak for WP7 was actually hired by Microsoft as "openness engineers", showing that Microsoft is at least willing to consider being more open than Apple.
The biggest hurdle to WP7 has been, in my experience, the salesmen. When I bought my Windows phone, the AT&T guy was so adamant that I was making the wrong choice that I had to call the manager to let me buy one. That particular AT&T store didn't even have a WP7 display on the floor (though others do). With Nokia now paying salesmen to push Windows Phone, that might change.
Why does that happen in the first place?
Makes sense, a good salesman is going to steer customers to maximize profits. This was taking it a bit too far, though. For the record, I've rarely reconsidered my purchase, and when I do my opinion is usually reversed when I load up the Zune app.