You also get the instinct to “parent” the poor and limit what they can buy.
Giving it to everyone isn’t the best idea but it’s the best way to keep politicians out of the kitchen.
(And I say this as someone who’s against the idea. But I do think the “universal” is the best idea within a bad idea.)
In the West, with the kicking out of the Church from the public sphere and the rise of hyperindividualism, many of the good works performed by the Church and the community was arrogated by the State. The State is now the uncontested institution, it is now the Church. Now these things become subject to and embroiled in all sorts considerations unrelated to the basic problem of dealing with someone in need. UBI entrenches the very isolating hyperindividualism that ruined the family and destroyed the resulting communities.
Second, what's stopping the world from immigrating to Canada to enjoy this social net? I believe we need tiers for new immigrants or international students. A person that has lived in Canada 30 years should be infront of the line for social assistance.
*The average family paid 45.2 per cent of their income in taxes to federal, provincial and local governments in 2022, estimates the Fraser Institute
I just want to clarify the position of it proponents.
We already do a version of what you're saying and it has a lot of administrative overhead and costs.
For example unemployment requires recipients to actively be looking for a job. Unless you have a doctor approved disability. Or you got a really bad flu and were stuck in bed for a week.
Then you have the people who go apply at the same place every week just to fill the requirement. Other people get an offer but come up with a reason why that job doesn't suit them, it's too far, etc.
So now you need to legislate all that stuff and validate it.
It gets complicated and expensive real quick.
So maybe it's cheaper to "waste" money paying some young/rich people, if you can save all the administrative work.
However, I would also bet the current system of multiple federal and provincial assistance programs with differing eligibility requirements and TONS of staff on the pay roll… might cost the same as “1 cheque per SIN”. It will massively ease up the stress on those systems, possibly even negate the need for quite a few of them. (Even if they don’t seem to plan on cutting any of them based on the article)
And on the access side, it’s much less effort, which is the ideal for someone that really needs it.
Also the cynical side of me thinks the Canadian banking oligopoly is excited about a monthly payment will be made into their client’s accounts.
Not so much when you realize that those with high incomes are just going to give their check right back via taxes . And that money is then used to send checks to others who don't make enough to have to give their check back.
Which is a fraction of the money that they already paid in taxes to fund the program in the first place. How was this not self-evident?
That said, I don't understand you very judgmental take about people wasting money on things you don't approve of. I hardly think buying clothes has a large moral imperative but even if someone does want to buy alcohol with their own money, I don't see how that is any of your concern. Also, just because people are "young and healthy" doesn't mean they aren't disadvantaged and need support.
https://www.canada.ca/en/revenue-agency/programs/about-canad...
In order to implement the filter, you now need enormous bureaucracies tasked with tracking and identifying people to filter, equally enormous agencies to enforce the filters, you get endless loop politicians fighting who should be filtered, you get endless lobbying pro and con filtering certain people, you get lots of people who make it their career to evade the filters and another even larger crowd who make it their purpose in life to persecute those who avoid the filter and on and on. All of this is pure waste on society.
That's why UBI is a better idea. Just pay to everyone, remove all the nonsense overhead from being able to exist and move on.
Doing what? Does it not even matter to you as long as it consumes 40+ hours every week of their productive lives?
A goal of UBI is to recognize that human value is not always realized via a paycheck (for example, a stay at home parent).