How about narrowing their intake of DMCA notices to certified mail? That ~$5 tax would go a log way to eliminate fraud.
It would also probably be mail fraud to submit a bogus claim.
Though there is a balance here that needs to be found.
I still find it a little wierd that those takedowns are sent to shops. What copyright are the shops violating?
I sent a certified letter a few weeks ago and was not required to show ID.
Sending certified mail in the United States absolutely does not require showing any identification at all. You can even do it all online.