I don't think this is particularly cultural. Most people who survived history did so through work so their children lived, or through raising children to be survivors. That's worth considering, instead of just blaming culture.
I don't think this is particularly cultural. Most people who survived history did so through work so their children lived, or through raising children to be survivors. That's worth considering, instead of just blaming culture.
Again, the monks believe they live rich lives without being "useful" by North American standards, that's certainly a cultural thing.
In North America our culture strongly believes a person's value is linked to their usefulness.
That's not up for debate really. I mean you can try to argue it's not, but honestly look around. Look at what value we place on people who are homeless, addicts, crippled, blind, deaf, or hell, even someone who is just unemployed.
We look down on them heavily. We judge them as having lower value because they are less useful.
Even look at the original comment and the disdain for "useless lumps"
This attitude doesn't exist everywhere. Don't try and say it's not cultural.
You seem to have only one counterexample: monks. Why would you assume that their highly unusual replacement of this by devotion to God is the less cultural option?
Do you need me to go and list all of the ways every culture on the planet has different views on the value of an individual?
I don't have that kind of time.
It's interesting to look at the social and political divisions that have been growing in Israel over the role of the Haredi (ultra-orthodox). The men are exempt from conscription and mostly don't work for wages. Instead they focus on religious study and survive on welfare and donations. More secular Israelis tend to resent the Haredi as useless lumps who don't do their fair share of work.
That's begging the question.
Historically, nearly all societies valued work because work was necessary; they valued being "useful".
Historically, nearly all societies also specialized, moving some folks away from directly producing/ harvesting food and to other jobs like building tools; they also produced art, philosophy, religion, and other things which don't appear to be "useful" but _empirically are_.
> Look at what value we place on people who are homeless, addicts, crippled, blind, deaf, or hell, even someone who is just unemployed.
> We look down on them heavily. We judge them as having lower value because they are less useful.
No. WTF, no.
Most people who are "unemployed" _were_ employed and _will soon be_ employed. Most people who are homeless had a home and will soon have a home. These are usually short term circumstances.
The folks who are long-term unemployed or long-term homeless are a completely different category: lots of substance abuse, mental issues they refuse to treat, refusal to adhere to basic societal norms, etc.
But if someone improves themselves, wow, do folks love a comeback story. I think that's almost universal across societies, but I'm happy to see evidence otherwise.
As for physically handicapped folks, plenty of them work for money. Some of them can't _but they want to_. And they find other ways to be useful to their families, their community, their society. I don't see disdain for that.
But that one is definitely cultural. Historically, most societies would "put them out of their misery". Still true in Canada.
> Even look at the original comment and the disdain for "useless lumps"
> This attitude doesn't exist everywhere.
Generally, yes, it does. See everything above.
Very different from modern corporate work culture, where you must appear to be working all the time, even if there's no work of value to do at a given time, and even if you worked day and night last month on a crunch project.
Very much cultural.
They also just did more. They didn't work to earn money to employ someone to work on their house; they went home and worked on their house. That might look to a simple observer as them working less, but I doubt the serf would see it that way.
The existence of something bad happening doesn't refute the point being made.
hint: it's your language.
Life prior to the industrial revolution sucked. It took a lot of backbreaking labour to produce basic necessities of life.