you fail to mention them.
you fail to mention them.
Windows has that stupid rule where LDAP runs all over the OS or nowhere at all, and Linux has that idea that LDAP is some add-on you assemble by connecting a jigsaw of pieces. Nothing makes it reasonable to publish a domain on the web, where people can authenticate on many of them, and send the tokens where needed.
(Well, actually Firefox does most of it, and you can use it and assemble the Linux pieces so it works. It just doesn't work in practice.)
Like as hackers we make fun of the phishing training that teaches you to avoid sketchy links in emails while simultaneously the real emails have the sketchiest links of all time. Using LDAP for this use-case is our version of that.
We should teach users to put their passwords into very few, limited, and trusted places. The cool new social app is NOT trusted. That random app on your phone is NOT trusted.
There's even an xkcd on this one: https://xkcd.com/792/
We should also teach to ourselves to throw away all those weird rules about passwords, like 6 to 15 characters max, letters and digits and a random set of punctuation characters liked by the site owner. Why those limits when they are storing a hash anyway?
go on, I'll wait.
Who knows what goes through people's heads.
You don't want your average user to have a great many usernames and passwords, maybe two or three at most to manage. You also probably don't want to have them share those credentials.. though without 'one big system' you can't really prevent that. You also probably want some kind of system with 2factor support through a few different methods, rolling code, sms, yubikey, etc.
LDAP ain't it.
From where I set Oauth seems to be the current solution with the least number of downsides. It's complicated for sure, the flows are easy to fuck up, but I haven't seen a better solution.
Maybe Passkey is it, i keep meaning to read the rundown but I just haven't found the time... and also it's realativly new enough that support and open source solutions might be a little sparse...
And yet it did.