Apple at least is under some pressure to not abuse it’s dominant position in the market. And more importantly that patents in this case seem just idiotic and shouldn’t be valid in the first place.
Apple has a precedent in monopolistic behavior that trolls don't provably have
Ah yeah?
Masimo claims violation of various patents for non-invasive blood data-collection via LEDs of specific wavelengths and photo-diodes in a specific geometry, patents to reduce power consumption of pulse oximeters as well as patents to detect when a pulse oximeter probe is misaligned on a patient.
They can demonstrate in the evolution of the Apple Watch how Apple launched their initial generation without such optimizations but found them to be necessary later-on, so it seems Masimo's patents are not that obvious.
In reaction, Apple countersues Masimo on the grounds of their DESIGN patent of the watch itself [1], among others based on design patents for a circular charging "puck" and the DESIGN of aligning LEDs, photodiodes and charging coil in a circular geometry. They basically claim that Masimo took unfair shortcuts in 2020 when designing a Smartwatch with a rectangular display, a geometric alignment of LEDs and photodiodes MASIMO ALREADY PATENTED and using a circular charging connector.
Ah. And Masimo already won TWICE with their claim as a judge upheld the ruling, so that's where we are now. A trillion dollar troll trying to frame himself as the victim.
[1] https://fingfx.thomsonreuters.com/gfx/legaldocs/zdvxdyorxvx/...