What Is Login.gov?
login.gov
login.gov
It's beyond ridiculous that a for-profit company (ID.me) was awarded a juicy, logo-plastering contract with the IRS. The notion that verifying your identity for tax purposes is a valid insertion point for middleman enterprise is absurd.
https://www.gsa.gov/about-us/newsroom/news-releases/us-gener... (“U.S. General Services Administration announces all Cabinet agencies are now using Login.gov”)
https://www.gsa.gov/about-us/newsroom/news-releases/gsa-and-... (“GSA and DOL expand Login.gov partnership to increase access, decrease fraud, and support modernization in unemployment insurance”)
I say nuanced because a person is probably using similar identification documents/id across agencies anyways
I can't tell you how confusing this is for my 70 year old father. I think login.gov is a fantastic idea but who ever decided to support three different login methods on a website designed for senior citizens .... AHHHHH. It's like torture for your chosen demographic and their children.
I think extra layers and MFA should be mandatory for a voting platform, perhaps even a physical MFA key that gets assigned and retrieved in person.
I am just tired of the US dragging their feet on digital voting when we have the technology.
Today's "sign the book at the poll, and we give you a ballot, which is one of 500 in this precinct-level box" provides at least some level of obfuscation.
I did vote in an election online. Back in 2000, the Arizona Democratic Party ran their (largely a token gesture) primary online as an proof of concept, and I cast my ballot from the main computer lab at ASU. It was convenient, but not breathtakingly more convenient than the mail-in balloting that is a major percentage of users today. Arguably, putting a physical ballot in people's hands is a really strong motivator to actually vote. Although even there, I'm a little more suspect about ballot secrecy; are they really keeping a firewall between the signed perjury declaration on the envelope and the ballot itself?
It's a question of trusting the government to be open about their security measures and not implementing a backdoor.
Dare I say that this software could be open source and shared with other governments. If it's properly secure enough, opening the source shouldn't be a problem, and opens it to public audit.