Having moved from an urban to a rural area, I disagree. There is far more food produced per person in rural areas. Although I'm in high desert, there's probably a surplus of calories created here even with non-producers like me included. We are relatively protected from starvation in a disaster because of this and the often very very short transportation lines from yard to table. Someone that already has a rabbit hutch or chicken coop or vegetable garden can scale up quickly. And out here you can live off of small game if you can shoot or trap, as the natives did for thousands of years.
But we're highly dependent on gasoline. I'd have a 22 mile round trip walk to a mini-mart without it. It would take a serious amount of cooperation and adaptation to maintain here without it. I'm not sure if it's sustainable for someone like me.
In the event of disaster I would rather be surrounded by a lower density of desperate, starving people.