I wouldn't be surprised if Gmail spam is higher-effort (like those individual SMS spam apps that politicians use) but higher-breakthrough.
I would be willing to wade through a number of additional spam emails to avoid losing important ones but of course this is Google so there is no user facing dial to adjust the sensitivity. Users just have to trust that Google's generalized approach is well calibrated for them.
I now skim my spam filter regularly because of this, but not everyone realizes they should do this.
Same, but I feel like it's almost kinda socially acceptable now. Happens to everyone and it's not something to get upset about... "oh, it wasn't me, it just went to spam." Like Gmail managed to alter our public norms instead of ensuring a zero false-positive rate :)
It sounds like a lot of people here check their spam folder regularly, which is good, but I don't know how widespread that is. I remember Gmail early on deemphasizing the spam folder since, in their view, the filtering was so good people didn't need to check it.
In the spam folder I just scroll down the list as fast as I can skim, and then close the tab if there's nothing.
If they were all just in my inbox I'd have to manually mark each one (and risk accidentally doing it to a real message while going through hundreds of messages).
There's no perfect solution here. Just personal preferences. I think I'd prefer a clean inbox with a 1% false positive rate vs having to manually flag a bunch of missed spam all the time.
I disagree with you. I use Postfix with rspamd plugged into it for my personal email account. I get way more spam to my gmail than I do to my personal account, and I sign up to everything with my personal account.
rspam also dkim signs my emails when I send them etc, verifies SPF/DKIM/DMARC on recipet etc.
Now to counter that - I am a TINY mail server - Probably 100 emails a day tops.
"I run my own mail server and get better spam results than Gmail"
Using Postfix+Rspamd gave me good insight into SPF, DKIM and DMARC and how to use them effectively.
rspamd is very, very impressive. I guess most of the hard work I've put into it is adding some of the not-turned-on-by-default things, like Pyzor and Razor. Also adding some other RBLs that weren't included by default (I spent a lot of time personally researching them and only picking ones that I believed to be of high value) The other big thing that I think is important is the RBL whitelists - DNSWL.org and HostKarma have a whitelist as well.
About one a week I spend 10-15 minutes looking at the logs of what it's accepted/rejected during the week to see if I can spot any obvious mistakes - it's pretty rare. If I do spot something I make config changes to address it. That said there's been months before where I haven't done this and none of the users of my platform have complained about spam (or missing email)
rspamd really is that amazing. I don't understand why more people don't scream it's praises from the rooftops.
Before I decided to leave it due to its horrendous false positive rate, gmail was driving like half of notification emails from my servers and mailing lists to spam, despite me never marking them as such. I was regularly missing important things.
It's much better with just regular client side bogofilter and some training on my personal mail/spam archive. And I do zero server side filtering, it's just all content based.
I don't care about capabilities, I just want near 0 false positive rate on the kind of email I receive (and not some common model), even at cost of some false negatives, and Gmail doesn't deliver there at all. And I don't want any arbitrary 5xx rejections for my senders, since I know how annoying that is on the sender side. Gmail will not guarantee that.
I think I have the opposite preference to you: false positives are OK to me if that means less spam gets through. In fact I've seen many of those notifications in my gmail spam and thought to myself, "Huh, you know, maybe I don't need those that badly after all... I'll just let gmail keep it there."
The overwhelming majority of my human contacts use other channels anyway (some chat app, or SMS), not email. I might get like ten real emails from humans in a year, and even then 90% of them are from people already in my contact list (and so bypass spam).
Phone calls are similar these days. Google Fi/Android also applies a similarly strict spam filter to incoming calls, and marks and blocks a lot of them as spam. I check once in a while, but overall I just don't really mind. If someone really needs to reach me they'll find a way... if they don't try, it's a good filter for how important their message really is anyway, lol.
I really wish Github had a DM feature =/ It feels so weird these days to email someone out of the blue.
And if you use non-GMail email providers, you would know they do fine. Not perfect, and of course it differs among providers, countries and accounts, but it's generally fine.
No it isn't.
> So today, we’re introducing new requirements for bulk senders — those who send more than 5,000 messages to Gmail addresses in one day
If you run an email server for personal use, you are quite unlikely to send more than 5k messages per day.
I avoided DKIM till 2018 when google started accepting my mail but silently sending it to the spam folder; so I wouldn't even get a reject message. I thought it'd be to onerous to implement but rspamd's dkim signing feature made it easy to use with my locally generated self-signed certs (and postfix).
It's been a long time since you've been able to set up your own email servers without DKIM and expect that your emails will get reliably delivered to Gmail users, especially for bulk mail.
The second requirement is more or less already a legal requirement in the US, and the third is literally how anti-spam has always worked - the only difference is that Google is now saying that they'll publish the threshold publicly, rather than keeping it a secret.
This is technically news, but it's hardly a major shift.
- non residential IP (I had to proxy through my VPS) - SPF - DKIM - use TLS with a modern cipher
And even with this, I still had to "favorite" (or whatever) AND set up a rule to "never send to spam" for my alerts@ sender address because I would still get them going to spam for no reason that I could find - I'd check the message and would see that SPF and DKIM PASSED and yet it was still going to spam.
I ended up switching to using webhooks to send alerts to a discord channel for a server that only had me in it. It works fine. It's a lot more surefire than trying to figure out email delivery
I have no problem with email deliverability to gmail/outlook. I think the difference is that my emails are two-way communication. I email someone, they email back or vice versa. Not a continuous stream of unreplied emails from my personal server to some gmail address (which does look like spam).
I imagine if you set up a script to reply to these emails from your gmail account with lorem ipsum and then deleted those replies after a few days, your problems will disappear.
Yes, you need to configure authentication (DKIM, rDNS and preferably DMARC) but you should be doing that anyway, the hard requirement doesn't change that.
One-click unsubscribe is required for bulk email, but you probably don't want to be sending bulk mail from your self-hosted solution anyway.
Anti-spam isn't killing the internet, spammers did.
I get spam messages once in a blue moon on my iPhone (specifically, on iMessage, I get recipients with a string of random letters ending in gmail.com). Ironically, it's ALWAYS a gmail.com or hotmail.com address. Funny how the overwhelming majority of spam I can remember comes from Gmail and Outlook, both of which love sending everyone else's messages straight into the spam tray, despite having DKIM + DMARC set up, static IP not on any Spamhaus blocklist, etc.
Imagine you live in an apartheid state and the people in power say: “White people will now refuse mail coming directly from black people. If black people want their mail to be received, they are required to send it through a trusted white liaison. If you're black and you don't like it, just make friends with other blacks and the tiny minority of whites who will accept mail from undesirables like you."
The above analogy is exaggerated of course, but I think there is a fundamental truth for it: large tech companies like Google have cornered the market by offering free solutions, and now they are imposing an apartheid system where mail sent through big companies is given priority over mail sent by real people who run their own email system.
(Personally, I've disabled all spam filters in Gmail since I've noticed that Gmail is likely to filter out legitimate email while the amount of spam I receive is actually very low.)
I get daily spam coming from Gmail and Azure tenants especially.
There is no such thing as the open and impartial internet. It's a melange of fiefdoms which only works through loose agreements between giant providers that tacitly allow all kinds of shit to happen in the hopes that they'll recoup the cost through their own business plans. The internet is quasi-open; open enough at the level that you interact with it that it "feels" open, sometimes. And it most certainly is not impartial. Competing interests have been warring over pieces of the pie for decades, and use whatever control they can grasp to make as much money as they can, while they can. Nerds running self-hosted servers and railing on about the inequities of corporate control on forums have absolutely no say.
> I get that spam is annoying (I hate it too) but letting giant American tech companies decide who is allowed to send email and who isn't is not the solution.
Again, they aren't. They have their own e-mail system, and you can use it or not. They aren't telling you you can't send your own e-mails or run your own systems. You are just upset that they have their own party and won't let you choose the music. You could throw your own party, but you don't want to do the work that entails, while you do want to force the people who are doing the work to do it your way, despite everyone else in the world not giving a shit and not wanting to deal with the problems anymore.
E-mail is not state sponsored racism. Again, you can choose what e-mail provider you use, and run your own mail system, and do whatever other asinine navel-gazing techno bullshit you want. Nobody is stopping you. They just aren't going to accept what you make. That's not oppression, that's called competition and free choice.
I'd be curious what you think of the telephone. Was that too intended to be some kumbaya international symbol of freedom that anyone could do anything they wanted with? Are you looking to run your own switchboard, and upset that AT&T won't carry your calls without forcing you to pay to hook up to their equipment? How dare they be able to reject your homemade lines to connect to their customers?
You want to know what actually not having a choice means? It means you can't even run your dinky mail server at home because the service is deemed illegal. That has not happened, and will not happen, because literally nobody cares about you and your e-mail service. You are the only person who cares about this. You are obsessed with a principle for the principle's sake, and the funny thing is, that principle isn't even being violated.
You want an end to the "tyrrany"? Use that engineering genius to come up with a solution to spam that doesn't revolve around IP reputation. Companies around the world will gladly take your mail if you can come up with a solution that doesn't require them to spend millions to mitigate spam.