Sequoia Set to Lead $500M Valuation Round for Instagram
allthingsd.com
allthingsd.com
This lends more to the notion that these "app builders" are falling backwards into business opportunities with no clear idea of how to execute.
Can't great apps just exist without the expectation of 1bn valuations and rolling them up as companies?
Running and maintaining Instagram probably comfortably costs in the six figures range with 30mm users. Operations at scale require venture capital funding. If Instagram were paid for, the user base would be a fraction - and more importantly, someone would just release a clone of the app for free, acquire millions of users, raise VC and crush you.
The opportunity cost of Instagram implementing a revenue model today is huge.
Given Instagrams popularity and influence I'd say there is no reason why it won't be as influential as YouTube -- $500mm is almost cheap when you think about it.
"Who realistically sets out to create a business that needs more than 30mm users to be plausible as a revenue generator?"
Swinging for the fence entrepreneurs. We should be supporting them. Instagram opportunities are once in a life time.
This is exactly the type of thinking I think we need less of. We shouldn't be encouraging people to play the lottery in hopes of a big, very-rare-chance-of-happening win.
We should be encouraging people to work hard to build real, profitable businesses.
Also, I hear rumors FB is acquiring Instagram for $1bn, which would be interesting for Sequoia.
It's not exactly the same thing as saying that these investors would be willing to buy all of Instagram for $500 million because both parties' utility functions are seldom linear. It's the closest thing we have, though.
If Sequoia got this deal with 2x liquidation preference then if Instagram is sold for $100 then Sequoia will still profit $50M. Correct?
Vested options and other term sheet items like 'participating preferred' make things more complicated, so you really have to read the entire term sheet to figure out who gets what under what circumstances.
Good resources: http://www.burningdoor.com/askthewizard/2007/04/venture_term... http://www.feld.com/wp/archives/2005/01/term-sheet-liquidati...
But, and its a huge "but", VC investments are almost always (especially series B like this one) preferred stock. This preferred stock gets (you guessed it) preferential treatment when compared to common stock, which is usually what founders have. Those preferences are numerous, arcane, and very significant.
For example, suppose an investor wants to invest $10M in a company for 50% of the stock. The entrepreneurs say, "no, we'll give you 30%. The investor says, "Fine. But I want a 3x liquidation preference. They do the deal. Later, the company is sold for $50M. In this case, the investor gets $30M (3x their investment, or 60% of the company) and everyone else gets $20M. So what was the real value the investor paid for? It's tough to tell because it depends on what happens next.
Now go an pile up several other terms like that and you can see how hard it is to truly imply the total value of the company from the price paid for preferred stock. In fact, it's impossible unless you know the terms (which are rarely public), and even then you're guessing.
In an interview with Sara Lacy, [1] Kevin Systrom notes that:
- "27 million people is not too shabby, but it’s nowhere near the scale you need to make a massively large business."
- they plan to build a tool for advertisers, because using the iPhone app is a "terrible experience" for them
[1] http://windonaleaf.net/post/20464525754/instagram-perform-ad... (via Shawn Blanc)
$2 is a fair price for the app-- too late now on that one. They could charge for filters.