1) Geeks _love_ to debate languages, especially one they _know better_
2) Geeks also love to trash languages that they don't know that well
3) There's always the claim of N-increase of productivity without any scientific backing (yet we always stress out that we should measure everything...seems like a paradox eh?)
4) This is how we do politics: debating languages, tools, frameworks.
Use whatever you like. That's the bottom line.
Joel used ASP.NET for FogBugz, ASP.NET MVC w/o ORM for SO.
LinkedIN, TripAdvisor, Jive, some Google properties are using Java.
Facebook, Flickr, WikiPedia use PHP.
You are far more productive using the tools you know.
If someone just picked up Node.JS (and a novice JavaScript developer) yesterday and claimed he/she got 10x productivity boost, ask him/her to show how they go about and code the solution a'la Notch (live-stream how you code or from pre-recorded coding session).
Building products require more than just a syntax. Libraries, Tools: build tools, packaging tools, deployment tools, documentation tools, etc are all as important as the programming language itself.
It's about time we ask for proofs, not just a blog post claim.