A lot of negative points, indeed, but the first priority is to ship new functionalities. If he was the only one focused on shipping, while you others loved to get lost in useless architectural debates, he was the best candidate to team leader.
Corollary 1: clean, maintainable code is only important when you have customers expecting maintenance.
Corollary 2: in the Real World (tm), the alternative to technical debt is getting out of business.