Who knows what the prices could have been had nuclear got the same level of subsidies.
Nuclear energy (especially fast neutron tech that can use the abundant U-238 and nuclear waste from existing NPPs) isn't getting attention it deserves. Only Russia, China and India are investing in it, but it's neglected in the West because there is no immediate profit to gain from this.
some historians argue that subsidizing nuclear tech too heavily was a major factor in the collapse of the ussr
I believe that Renewables should be subsidized, and current progress is great, but total decarbonization is easier to realistically achieve together with nuclear energy.
If you support renewables, you don’t have to be anti-nuclear at all.
it's plausible that further subsidies could have made nuclear power cheap. the long pole in the tent seems to be the cost of the steam turbine generator, though, which isn't cost-competitive with pv even if the heat to make the steam is free. this is after a century of improvements, and the steam turbine is the main electric power source of every rich economy in the world and most of the poor ones. so i'm not sure a few trillion dollars more in subsidies would change that
And yet some "renewables-only" people want to rely on gas turbines for the times of unfavorable weather conditions.
And, the turbines are still more efficient (46% efficiency with modern Siemens turbines), and the heat that isn't going into the turbine steam can still be used elsewhere, like for district heating or for industrial purposes, which makes the overall system very high yield.
In comparison, photovoltaics is currently at 20% efficiency. Wind is at 60% but it's quite intermittent and unpredictable.
a couple of quibbles, tho
the efficiency of photovoltaics and wind is only relevant here if you're powering them from stored energy, such as white-hot graphite blocks, rather than from the sun. or in the far future when human energy consumption has grown by two orders of magnitude
gas turbines are only 'renewables-only' if you make the gas from renewable energy
There are ways to make hydrocarbons from atmospheric carbon (using any energy, including renewable) but that is nightmarishly inefficient. Anti-nuclear people's plan though is to use good ol' fossil gas for the times when the weather is unsuitable for renewables.
>the efficiency of photovoltaics and wind is only relevant here if
Agreed, you can disregard its efficiency if the source energy is free.
Fission energy is so high yield that it's also basically free, just like the Sun or wind, with the difference of being able to increase/decrease production on demand. It's the infrastructure to extract that energy that costs money, and those costs could be improved with proper R&D, investments, subsidies and economies of scale, just like with renewables.
I do believe nuclear is the part of the Solution together with renewables. At least we will need nuclear before solar extraction and storage are so advanced that they can power the grid all the time by themselves. Yes, that future is certainly is not very far away, but we can't afford much time to start decarbonizing.
water electrolysis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electrolysis_of_water#Efficien... is about 80% efficient, except that there's an experimental capillary-fed process that is supposedly 98% efficient
i wouldn't call that 'nightmarishly inefficient', particularly if you can do it at hours when electricity prices would otherwise be zero or negative because of abundant solar or wind power
but i don't know how efficient carbon dioxide reduction is https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carbon_capture_and_utilization
nuclear power plants are not normally highly dispatchable, though obviously the naval ones are
It's only to get hydrogen, also there is cost to make it liquid, to store it (it's neither trivial nor cheap) and to extract energy from it in fuel cells.
>i don't know how efficient carbon dioxide reduction is
If we want to capture carbon from atmosphere and turn it back into hydrocarbon fuel like gas or diesel, thus achieving net zero emissions, that process is still "nightmarishly inefficient". There is a startup that I'm watching (Prometheus Fuels) that promises to do that cheaply, but there haven't been any positive news from them recently
https://theicct.org/e-fuels-wont-save-the-internal-combustio...
There is lots of (paywalled) proper economic analysis of current methods of Electrofuel generation from atmospheric carbon, the summary is that the current processes cost multiple times more than similar fossil fuels, with the main cost factor being the cost of electrolyzed hydrogen per kg, and captured atmospheric carbon cost per kg, and all of that comes down to the cost of the energy consumed during the process.
https://www.carboncommentary.com/blog/2021/11/18/how-much-wi...
Edit: other than any research, the main indicator (for me) is that nobody hasn't yet offered renewables based liquid hydrogen or atmospheric carbon Electrofuel at nearly viable prices for today's world. If the technology was energy efficient, these fuels would be flooding the market already even at 2x the price, but the cost of producing these is currently 5x or higher. That's why the first target for such fuels is commercial aviation and sea transportation where the cost of fuel can be absorbed less painfully.
and it's fantastic news that the main cost factor is the cost of the energy input, rather than, for example, defouling or catalyst replacement. because once the electric grid is mostly renewable and intermittent, so that energy is free in the daytime, synthetic fuels will be immensely cheaper than they are now. perhaps by even more than 5x :)
initially the carbon dioxide won't come from atmospheric capture; carbon capture at the source is immensely cheaper. perhaps as the number of fossil-fuel and biomass point sources dwindles, atmospheric carbon capture will become competitive, but i suspect that it may
16% cycle efficiency might rule out liquid synfuels for grid-scale energy storage, but hydrogen should be closer to 50% (60% combined-cycle turbine times 80% electrolysis), or perhaps higher with fuel cells, and though that's much lower than batteries, it's still a viable alternative to nuclear if batteries don't work out due to shortages or whatever
Numbers just aren't written that way. I don't know if you realise it, but that silly affectation is offputting enough to hinder your cause more than help it.
The nuclear industry actually has been running on subsidies. Also in China and Russia. It would not survive long without them. And of course this whole industry was bootstrapped via massive defense spending. Trillions in today's money.
There's no such thing as an unsubsidized profitable nuclear plant. That's why investors are pulling the plug on this thing. Because even with the (massive) subsidies, it just does not add up to anything remotely financially feasible. Unsubsidized LCOE is off by about an order of magnitude where it should be now. Never mind in a few decades.
And of course the cost of securing them, dealing with the waste, or decommissioning them is typically also subsidized. To the point where that's commonly not even factored into the projected cost for nuclear because that is depressing enough without that. Somebody (i.e. tax payers) should take care of all that. Not their problem. Most current nuclear waste is stored in temporary locations while people figure out how to actually pay for all that. That was the plan seventy years ago and there still is no solution. Those sites need security. Which of course costs money. And eventually "somebody" might do something about it. At great cost.
All of it subsidized. By past, current, and future generations.