I'd add a requirement that said doctor have practiced in the relevant specialty within the last decade.
Maybe you make it like jury duty; if you're a practicing doc, you periodically get randomly assigned some appeals in your speciality to review.
The current system already has a massive quid-pro-quo; if you aren't willing to spend 1.2 seconds to deny tens of thousands of claims a month (not an exaggeration! https://www.propublica.org/article/cigna-pxdx-medical-health...), they'll find someone else. The docs and companies doing these "independent" reviews are completely captured by the industry already.
Or send appeals to a committee of randomly-rotating reviewers. The state could administer the service to promote fairness and lessen the cost to the insurer.